Smart,Safe,Secure Browser

The Indian voter is the reason we don't have political debates

America's voters have an intellectual engagement with their country's politics. This is unthinkable in India, where voting is done on the basis of tribal identity.

Indian voters make their choices based on identity and not argument: Reuters

by Aakar Patel 21 Oct 08:50 am IST

     

It is with admiration and shame that we must watch the debates between Republican Romney and Democrat Obama.

Admiration, because they operate in a society where debate decides the mind of voters. This aspect became more remarkable when we saw that the election turned after the first exchange between Romney and Obama.

This means America's voters have an intellectual engagement with their country's politics. That they hold judgment on the candidate till they hear from him what his position is, on the things that concern them, and then weigh it against the position of his opponent. This is unthinkable in India, where voting is done on the basis of tribal identity. Here is where we must feel a little shame. Here Patels vote as Patels, Dalits as Dalits, Muslims as Muslims, and Lingayats as Lingayats.

All our parties are actually coalitions of castes, even our ideological parties. The BJP is the party of Lingayats and upper castes in Karnataka, where I live. The Janata Dal here is the party of peasant Vokkaligas and Muslims. The majority in these communities votes for the corresponding parties. This is accepted and unremarked upon.

Policy, intellect, debate, principle - all of that is reduced to identity. Certainly it is true that it is such tribal identity that has kept India democratic, since there is little to separate political parties in terms of policy. In the absence of such voting by identity, as we observe elsewhere on the Indian subcontinent, democracy wilts. But one wonders, when witnessing the manner of the American voter, when the Indian voter will move on from this.

The idea that someone might be undecided about voting Republican or Democratic till they hear the candidate's policy positions is an entirely civilised one. We must recognise this in the American voter.

It is true of course that there are communal voters in America as well. For instance the blacks, called African-Americans there, vote in tribal fashion for Obama. So do the Mormons, a small....
Page 1 2 >

#India #Barack Obama #InMyOpinion #Caste #Mitt Romney #US Presidential Election 2012 #community #Identity Politics #Town Hall debates